RSS

Innovations in National Guard Officership in WWI

Camp Cody 34th ID

Innovations in National Guard Officership in WWI

At the onset of World War I, military officership was formed around ideas of education, class, and noblesse oblige.  Officers in both the National Guard and Regular Army were usually selected through personal or political connections and trained through apprenticeship.  Increasing the size of the officer corps by 20,000 men in two years in preparation for World War I forced the army to develop a system of standardized officer training and selection which more closely mirrors today’s ideals of meritocracy—a chance for army regulars, guardsmen and draftees to test their methods of selection and training on the battlefield.

The largest source of officer commissions in World War I by far was through the Officer Training Camps, or OTCs. Incredibly, 74% of Army officers in WWI* were commissioned with just 90 days of standardized training.  National Guard officers were the next largest group, making up 9% of officer ranks, while regular officers comprised just 5%. Even with the Dick Act of 1903, which pushed for professionalization in the guard, federalizing National Guard officers and graduates of “Plattsburg” military training camps had failed to produce the consistent quality or quantity of officers needed for rapid growth.  The OTCs, revolutionary in their scale, were established with only 14-15 weeks of preparation time to establish a system of screening applicants, building camp infrastructure, developing training regimes and assigning the newly commissioned officers to their divisions before the draftees arrived.  One of largest problems in growing the army so quickly at the outset of the declaration of war was assigning the current regular army and National Guard officers to greatest effect. These first cadres were made of a combination of regular army and National Guard officers.

While college graduates were preferred, the army relaxed its requirement for college attendance, placing more discretion in the OTCs in selecting candidates who had shown leadership in their civilian careers. In selection, the army turned to the nascent felt of psychology and intelligence testing, which has progressed considerably but never been abandoned by the army since.  These citizen soldiers in the initial classes, drawn from volunteers from colleges, businesses and local communities proved to be some of the most educated, intelligent and motivated officers the army had seen.

Mobilized regular army, National Guard and National Army units all faced an overwhelming influx of personnel transfers and unit re-designations leading up to their deployments.  Regular army and OTC officers were often transferred into National Guard units, and experienced soldiers and NCOs were transferred into new divisions and replaced by draftees.  Popular wisdom passed on to new officers in the OTC system was that the National Guard style of leadership was chummy and often faltered into fraternization.  Regular Army Officers complained that the National Guard units held close ties that undermined discipline when officers were reluctant to interfere with social and business relationships after the war.  However, the same relationships were said to motivate officers, since a poor performance as an officer would mire their personal and professional lives in the communities.  It’s unclear how much National Guard officers were actually different, but it’s important to note that the influx of new draftees and war-motivated volunteers were also different.  It was a ‘citizen army’ now and a culture which encouraged honest discussion between officer and enlisted, now a common ideal in units, was dubious to the West Point and OTC lieutenants and hard-boiled sergeants of the time.

Considering that the Army began the war with only 17,00 Regular Army, National Guard and Army Reserve Officers, the fact that the first two OTC sessions graduated 44,578 new officers was no small feat.  Moreover, it represented the first time in U.S. Army history where the majority of officers had standardized training. The National Guard officers of the era supplied knowledge and experience to the OTC program and in the battlefield, and helped to develop a more egalitarian form of leadership in the army.  Meanwhile, the army’s push for equal opportunity in selection and training paid dividends back into the National Guard as it set the precedent in officer selection and training we see in our modern National Guard.

               

Sources:

Faulkner, Richard.  School of Hard Knocks: Combat Leadership in the American Expeditionary Forces.  College Station, Texas A&M Press, 2012.

Doubler, Michael. I Am the Guard: A History of the Army National Guard 1636-2000. Washington, Government Printing Office, 2001.

*this excludes direct commissions for fields such as medical, dental and chaplain.  Overall, 48% of total officers commissioned through OTCs.

About the author:  Miranda Summers Lowe is a captain in the DC National Guard.  She is currently serving on the OEF Study Group at the Army Center of Military History.

Herman G. Leitz’s Headlines

By Montana Coward Herman G. Leitz with His Newspaper Headlines(Courtesy of Carl Hartup/ The News-Sentinel August 14, 1985) Herman G. Leitz, an Indiana man working as a security guard at the Studebaker plant during World War II, collected almost 1,000 American newspaper headlines documenting the war. Leitz was frustrated by his small recollection of the [...]

The 9/11 Era Gallery Memorial Wall

New York Army Guard Specialist Roshan Singh Lost his Life at the World Trade Center on 9/11. By Kevin Brown Over 800 National Guard members have made the ultimate sacrifice since September 11, 2001. Several Guard members died in the horrific 9/11 attacks at the Pentagon and World Trade Center. One of these members was [...]

The National Guard’s State Partnership with Ukraine

U.S. Army Maj. Gen. David Baldwin, adjutant general of the California National Guard, Volodymyr Zelenskyy, president of Ukraine, and California Lt. Gov. Eleni Kounalakis, visited the California Air National Guard’s 129th Rescue Wing at Moffett Air National Guard Base, California, Sept. 2, 2021.(Courtesy of national guard.mil) By Kevin Brown The National Guard’s State Partnership Program [...]

Remembering The Bataan Death March

By William Roulett Capt. Edward Lingo(Courtesy of the New Mexico National Guard Museum) April 9, 2022, marks the 80th anniversary of the start of the Bataan Death March. Orchestrated by the Imperial Japanese Army, some 60,000-80,000 American and Filipino Prisoners of War (POWs) were brutally forced to march more than 60 miles from Mariveles, at [...]

The Career of Maj. Gen. Roberta V. Mills

Maj. Gen. Roberta V. MillsMarch 18, 1938 – April 20, 2021(Courtesy of Roberta V. Mills Estate) By William Roulett As Women’s History Month draws to a close, we at the National Guard Memorial Museum reflect on the life of Major General Roberta V. Mills. Mills accomplished much in her 83 years, including a 33-year career [...]

President Lincoln’s Militia Service

President Lincoln’s Militia Service (Courtesy of NGEF) By Kevin Brown Abraham Lincoln served as the 16th President of the United States from 1861 before being assassinated in 1865. During his early days in office, the United States plunged into a bloody civil war between northern and southern states over slavery. Prior to his presidency, Lincoln, [...]

“The Black Devils” of the Illinois National Guard 370th

Troops of the 370th in France(Photo Courtesy of Army.mil) By: Kevin Brown Since the Revolutionary War, African Americans have made countless contributions to the National Guard. Prominent segregated National Guard units distinguished themselves during the First World War, such as Illinois’ 370h infantry regiment. Unlike the Harlem Hell fighters, which formed just before the Great [...]

1918 Spanish Flu

  In January and February of 1918, a flu virus quietly spread through sleepy Haskell County, Kansas, with a human population of 1,720 dispersed over nearly 600 acres.  By the time the Spanish Flu burnt itself out globally, over 21,000,000 people would be dead.     As the virus worked its way through Haskell County, young American [...]

Intern Ginger Miroy Raises PTSD Awareness

Always Ready, Always There: My Story of Hope                 September 11, 2001 was a defining moment for many of us, but even more so for CW4 Clifford Bauman. CW4 Bauman was on his way to the Pentagon when American Airlines Flight 77 struck the building, and Bauman sprang [...]

Bill’s Maudlin Humor

Bill’s Maudlin Humor: WWII as seen through the cartoons of Bill Mauldin By: Lauren Wong December 7, 1941 was the day the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor; it was also the day the U.S. entered WWII. When the Army shipped out, they brought nine Divisions of National Guardsmen with them. The 45th ID was one of [...]